Employment law

Law, collective agreement, company agreement, internal rules, contract: which rule prevails?

6 October 2026

Tuesday morning at Farakan Agro: the packing line is running at full speed and the HR director has five documents open on her desk. Aminata’s contract provides for eight days’ notice, the Labour Code for one month; the establishment agreement promises higher severance pay than the Code; the internal rules punish each late arrival with a 5,000 XOF deduction. Which one applies? Pick the wrong text and you pay twice: once to the employee, once to the court.

1. Five texts, five authors

Farakan Agro is a fictitious fruit-processing company with 120 employees near Bamako: its name and situation are used purely as an example. Like any company of its size, it operates under five texts at once, written by different authors and checked in different ways.

TextWho writes itCheck before it appliesWhat it can do
Law and implementing texts (Labour Code, decrees, orders)The StateOfficial adoption and publicationSet common rules and minimums
Collective agreementWorkers’ unions and employers’ organisations, or employers(L.70)Approval (visa) by the Minister, then filing with the labour courtregistry (L.73, L.74)Improve on the law for one or more sectors
Establishment agreementThe employer, the staff delegates and the most representative unions(L.88)Approval (visa) by the Minister (L.73, made applicable by L.88)Adapt the agreement to the company, add benefits
Internal rulesThe head of the company, after consulting staff delegates (L.64,L.65)Approval (visa) by the labour inspector (L.66)Organise work, discipline, health and safety, and wage payment
Employment contractThe employer and the employeeFiling or approval in some cases (fixed-term contracts over threemonths, foreign workers)Set individual terms

A collective agreement is a written agreement on working conditions, negotiated between workers’ unions and employers or their organisations. An establishment agreement is negotiated within the company itself, to adapt the collective agreement to its specific conditions. Internal rules are the document drawn up by the head of the company, compulsory in any industrial, commercial or agricultural business with at least ten employees (article L.62).

2. The basic rule: a floor, then the most favourable

The law sets a floor. A collective agreement may contain provisions more favourable to workers than laws and regulations, but it cannot depart from their public-policy provisions (Labour Code, article L.70). A public-policy provision is a mandatory rule: no agreement or contract can set it aside.

The same mechanism operates at every level. When an employer is bound by a collective agreement, it applies to the employment contracts the employer concludes, unless a contract clause is more favourable to the employee (Labour Code, article L.77). The establishment agreement adapts the collective agreement to the company and may add more favourable clauses (article L.88).

This is known as the favourability principle: when two applicable texts conflict, the one most favourable to the employee prevails. Why? Because the employee negotiates alone with the employer: the Code guarantees a baseline that no written document can take away.

“The Code sets the floor. Every text below it can go up, never down.”

The Code itself applies this principle to severance pay. It sets rates (20% per year for the first five years, 25% from the sixth to the tenth, 30% beyond), but allows collective and establishment agreements to provide more favourable rates, which then replace its own (Labour Code, article L.53).

Example. Farakan’s establishment agreement provides 30% per year from the first year. Aminata earns 300,000 XOF per month and has four years of service:

Under the Code: 20% × 300,000 × 4 years = 240,000 XOF
Under the agreement: 30% × 300,000 × 4 years = 360,000 XOF
Amount due: 360,000 XOF, i.e. 120,000 XOF more

The most common mistake

Believing that the most recent text, or the one closest to the company, always prevails. Neither the date nor the proximity decides: first comes the legal floor, then the rule most favourable to the employee.

What you need to do

  • Keep the Code, the applicable collective agreement, establishment agreements, internal rules and contract templates in a single file.
  • Compare what each text provides before any decision: dismissal, bonus, notice.
  • Apply, between two applicable texts, the one most favourable to the employee.

3. When the Code’s figure is only a fallback

On several subjects, the Code gives its figure only “in the absence” of a collective agreement or company agreement. If the applicable agreement covers the question, it is the first text to read.

SubjectThe Code’s figureWhen it applies
Notice period8 days to 3 months depending on category (L.41)“In the absence of collective agreements or decrees in lieu”
Overtime premiums10% to 100% depending on the time and day (L.137)“In the absence of a collective agreement or a company orestablishment agreement”
End-of-contract payment (fixed-term)2.5% of total gross pay (L.24; Decree No. 96-178, art. D.24-1)If no rate is set by a collective agreement
Minimum wages by categorySet by decree (L.96)In the absence of a collective agreement

For Aminata, paid monthly, the eight-day clause does not stand: without a collective agreement, her notice is at least one month (Labour Code, article L.41). If Farakan is bound by a collective agreement, its notice period must be checked first. See also our article Notice period in Mali. And to identify the agreement that binds your company, see Which collective agreement applies to my company?

The most common mistake

Calculating notice or overtime with the Code alone, without opening the collective agreement. The calculation is then wrong from the first line.

What you need to do

  • Open the applicable collective agreement before calculating any notice, overtime or end-of-contract payment.
  • Use the Code’s figures only where no collective or company agreement provision applies.

4. Internal rules: short, approved and without fines

Internal rules are compulsory from ten employees in industrial, commercial and agricultural businesses (Labour Code, article L.62). But their scope is narrow: they may only cover the technical organisation of work, discipline, health and safety, and the arrangements for paying wages (article L.64). They therefore cannot change pay or other terms of the contract.

They then go through two filters. Staff delegates send their observations within fifteen days (article L.65). The labour inspector approves the text and may require the removal of clauses contrary to laws, regulations and collective agreements in force (article L.66). The rules take effect twenty days after approval (article L.68). They must then be displayed: see Which documents must the employer display?

The clause that never stands

Farakan’s internal rules provide for a 5,000 XOF deduction for each late arrival. That is a fine, and the Code prohibits employers from imposing fines (articles L.69 and L.121). Lateness can be penalised, but through a disciplinary sanction, never through a deduction of money.

What the unlawful clause costs

An employer who imposes a fine faces a criminal fine of 20,000 to 100,000 XOF; for a repeat offence, 40,000 to 200,000 XOF and imprisonment of 15 days to 3 months, or one of these two penalties (article L.318). The fine is incurred as many times as there are offences (article L.335). And the sums deducted remain owed to the employees.

For the full method, see our articles Internal rules and Drafting internal rules.

What you need to do

  • Review the internal rules and remove any fine or deduction clause.
  • Check that each clause falls within one of the four permitted areas.
  • Submit any new version to the staff delegates, then to the labour inspector for approval.

5. The contract: it can give more, never less

Contracts are freely concluded (article L.14). That freedom stops at the floor set by the law and by collective texts. Here is how four common clauses are settled.

Contract clauseWhat the Code saysEffect
8 days’ notice for a monthly-paid employeeAt least one month, without a collective agreement (L.41)The legal notice applies
Cash payment instead of annual leaveAgreement void, except on termination before leave entitlement(L.162)The leave remains due
2-year non-compete covering all of MaliSix months and 15 km at most, and only in specified cases(L.17)Clause at risk of being void
35 days of leave per yearThirty days per year (L.151)Valid clause, as it is more favourable

The most common mistake

Thinking that a clause signed by the employee is necessarily valid. The Code says it clearly for the final settlement receipt: the employee’s waiver of rights under the contract cannot be used against them (article L.111). See also our article Non-compete clause and, for activities carried on during the contract, Can an employee work elsewhere outside working hours?

What you need to do

  • Screen your contract templates against the Code and the applicable collective agreement.
  • Correct any clause less favourable than these texts before the next hire.

A closer look: no “reversal of the hierarchy of norms” in Mali

In France, reforms in 2016 and 2017 gave company agreements priority over sector agreements on many subjects. Much of the content in circulation repeats this logic. It has no equivalent in Mali.

In Mali, the purpose of an establishment agreement is to adapt collective agreements to the company’s specific conditions, and it may contain more favourable clauses (Labour Code, article L.88). The rules of article L.77 apply to it: the collective agreement prevails, except for provisions more favourable to the employee.

Only one flexibility is provided: the agreement may adjust how a pay rise decided by the collective agreement is applied, provided the total wage bill increases at least as much as if the rise had been applied as is (article L.88). See also Establishment agreement and Drafting an establishment agreement in Mali.

Key takeaways in 6 points

  1. Start from the Code: it sets the floor that no one can lower.
  2. Then open the applicable collective agreement: for notice, overtime or minimum wages, it is often the one that gives the figure.
  3. Apply, between two applicable texts, the one most favourable to the employee.
  4. Limit internal rules to their four areas and include no fines.
  5. Never rely on the employee’s signature to validate a clause less favourable than the law or the collective agreement.
  6. Use the establishment agreement to adapt and improve, never to reduce.